Review: Death in the Spires, by KJ Charles

I've loved KJ Charles since I stumbled across her historical fiction a few years ago, starting with Band Sinister, a sort of frothy gender-flipped combination of Georgette Heyer's Venetia and Sylvester, progressing to the wonderful caper/crime/romance Any Old Diamonds, reveling in the supernatural adventure/romances of This Spectred Isle and the Magpie Lord trilogy, and various other fun romps that combine crime/suspense/adventure and romance. Charles' latest book, Death in the Spires (being released April 11), is not a romantic romp like many of her others, but it is a gripping, immersive, deeply engaging and well told mystery.

It opens in 1905 with clerk Jeremy Kite being shown an anonymous letter that his employer had received, accusing him of killing Toby Feynsham. Yet again he has lost a job due to a scandalous unsolved mystery from 10 years ago, when he was one of "The Seven Wonders," a close circle of shining students at Oxford. After Toby, the leader of the group, had been found murdered, Jeremy had been unable to concentrate on exams and dropped out into obscurity. Now, he reaches out to the others to find out if they've been plagued with similar accusations, and finally decides to find out who ruined his life by killing Toby.    

I've read plenty of books set at Oxford (the Spires of the title) between the World Wars. This is a bit earlier than that, but the only major change I saw was that in 1895, women weren't yet awarded degrees, although they were allowed to study there. So there only a couple of women were members the charmed circle. One of the students was Black. Jeremy himself was lame in one leg and a scholarship student from a poor background to boot (and secretly homosexual). Toby, however, had drawn all these apparent misfits into his circle, and for a while they brought out the best in each other.

A decade after Toby's death, some of the others are doing just fine, at least on the surface, but others have fallen nearly as far as Jeremy. However, they have mostly moved on and want him to drop the matter. Despite warnings, pressure, and eventual attacks, Jeremy perseveres in his investigation, traveling across the country to question his former friends and others who might know anything, and returning to Oxford to dig for clues in the past. Secrets are revealed, old wounds are revived, and old relationships are renewed, for good or ill.

Death in the Spires was a compelling page-turner; I raced through it in one night. The protagonist is highly sympathetic and relatable, and the other characters in the group are sharply drawn. The writing is evocative, and the revelations throughout the book and at the end were surprises but felt natural after all. I highly recommend this book to anyone interested in historical mysteries, especially anglophiles.

Content warnings: Death, violence of various forms, a few short sex scenes, and negatively portrayed sexual and racial discrimination and ableism.

Comps: Gaudy Night by Dorothy Sayers

Disclaimers: I received a free eARC of this book via NetGalley.